Chiming in on Rob Bell’s LOVE WINS

Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever LivedOnce in a while a book comes along that gets people all riled up, bringing forth either enthusiastic praise or vehement wrath. Such a book is LOVE WINS: A BOOK ABOUT HEAVEN, HELL, AND THE FATE OF EVERY PERSON WHO EVER LIVED by Rob Bell. Check out the 563 customer reviews at Amazon to get a flavor of the furor.

Bell is the founding pastor of the Mars Hill Bible Church in Grand Rapids, Michigan. He bears a respectable educational pedigree from Wheaton College and Fuller Theological Seminary. So what has he done to cause such a stir? The buzz claimed “Rob Bell says there is no hell.”

To many outside the church such a belief solicits a “So what, who cares?” response. But to the thousands of believers who define their faith on the tenet of eternal damnation unless one makes a public profession of faith in Jesus Christ, them is fightin’ words.

I decided I needed to read the book and judge for myself. This was my first exposure to Bell, who is surely an engaging speaker. The style of the book reads like an interesting sermon series. It begs to be read aloud. The placement of words on the page is often poetical.

For emphasis.

Rather than a pedantic expression of his opinions, Bell asks a lot of questions about the basic beliefs of scores of Protestant churches. He is logical—and disturbing. If God is an “all loving Father,” then how can he cast his children into everlasting fire? Hmmm.

For Bell, the question isn’t so much about what happens “over there,” but what is happening “here.” Is there a hell? Open the newspaper, read about the wars, famine, mass executions in Mexico, the domestic violence, sexual slavery. Hell? Why sure.  It is here and now.

The real question is how to bring forth “Your Will on Earth as it is in Heaven” as envisioned in the Lord’s Prayer. Bell’s answer is coming into relationship with the living Christ. The expansive, can’t-be-contained or-totally-understood Messenger of the Good News.

Bell speaks to the disenfranchised, the people turned off by the fire and brimstone message. He breaks down the dogmatic walls. For those comfortably dwelling within those walls, he is a heretic. For those outside the walls, he offers hope.

3 comments on “Chiming in on Rob Bell’s LOVE WINS

  1. Although I haven’t read the book, I feel comfortable with the treatise of dissatisfaction with current “explanations” of Scripture over the existence of heaven and hell. I organize my thoughts around the concept that arguing with the living Creator is the source of mankind’s problems and will lead each and every person toward a living hell, and finally death. Always. Universally. Forever.

    Hearing God’s messages, acknowledging their value, and responding accordingly will lead each and every person to heaven. Immediately. Completely. Freely. The choice is ours, but in order to leave this world for His Kingdom, we have to stop listening to the deception, arrogance and “leaven” of man’s speculation and understanding, whether it comes from elected representatives, corporate spin doctors or pompous theologians.


  2. I think we’re entering an age where people are beginning to think for themselves, which shakes up all the establishments. Makes me wonder what “religion” on planet Earth will look like in 100 years. Feels like lots of walls are tumbling down.

    • People “thinking for themselves” can be a euphemism for either looking for inner certainty or for following their own understanding – it really depends what conclusions we form. I like to believe that truth is simple … it’s information without important gaps and without adding wild imaginations to it. Religion itself is (and always has been) harmless communion with God and one another, until the focus of attention is usurped by human fantasy. I understand Jesus’ claim to be “equal with God” to mean that He refused to see himself as greater than God, unlike the Jewish teachers of his time. In His day, the walls that divided people came crashing down from the power of His message. I look forward to a revival of that message.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.